THE VATICAN HAS NO NEED FOR THIS KIND OF IMITATIO

By bishop “Paula”
– bishop Paula-Willemijn van Rooijen, Old Catholic Apostolic Church,
diocese Europe

This article highlights an argument that usually remains out of the spotlight. It is about the fact that there are various matters that cannot be traced back to Jesus but were decided by the later church. At the same time, the Roman Church invokes the fact that no women were elected to the Twelve Apostles as an argument for not ordaining women. That’s not logical at all, now is it?

Let’s explore the discourse a bit further.

In 1976 Inter Insigniores was published. A statement from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (the former Inquisition) that describes the reasons for not ordaining women.[1]

The document discusses the various theological and historical reasons why ordination to the priesthood in the Roman Catholic Church can only be given to men. Inter Insigniores concludes that the Church “does not consider itself the authority that can admit women to priestly ordination.” Arguments mentioned include: the example given in the New Testament of Christ who chose only men as apostles and the constant practice of the Church that, following Christ, has only chosen men.

In response to Inter Insigniores, John Wijngaards wrote in 1977 Did Christ Rule Out Women Priests?[2] The book is published on the internet.[3]

John Wijngaards (1935) is a theologian and a priest who became an advocate of women’s ordinations and therefore gave up the priesthood.

Wijngaards writes: “If we want to take the Roman document seriously – and there is no reason why we shouldn’t – the exclusion of women from the priesthood is based, not on a prejudiced attitude towards the sexes, but on an historical fact (Christ excluded women) explained as a norm (women cannot be priests). The crucial question is: Is this interpretation correct? Was Christ’s preference for men a practical expedient, dictated by the expectations of society in his times, or did it express a doctrinal preference which laid down a principle to be followed in all ages to come? Was the masculine character of ministers in the early Church an accident of social organization, or was it a deliberate element of the sacramental sign? Rome says the choice of a male minister was deliberate, was doctrinal, was sacramental and normative for all times.”[4]

In the years following the publication of Inter Insigniores, Rome strengthened its opposition to the ordination of women, culminating in Ordinatio Sacerdotalis (1995) and subsequent documents that further restricted theologians’ freedom of discussion: Responsum ad Dubium (1995), Ad Tuendam Fidem (1998).[5]

In protest, Wijngaards resigned from his priesthood on September 17, 1998. “As I view Rome’s ban on the ordination of women as not valid, not based on Scripture or Tradition, not arrived at after proper consultation in the Church, detrimental to ecumenism and highly detrimental to the spiritual well-being of the faithful, I feel obliged in conscience to continue to express my sincere opposition.” [6]

Wijngaards has continued to publish his reasons for advocating the ordination of women to the Catholic priesthood in a series of books, most notably The Ordination of Women in the Catholic Church[7]  and No Women in Holy Orders?[8] In 1999 he founded a website that has become the largest Internet library specializing in the ordination of women: Wijngaards Institute for Catholic Research.[9]

In The Ordination of Women in the Catholic Church Wijngaards also discusses matters on which Jesus did not make any explicit decision, but on which the later church did.[10]

We’re back to where the article started. The fact that the church in later times decided on matters about which Jesus did not make any explicit decision is important for the consistency of the Roman point of view that women cannot be ordained.

Wijngaards asks the question: “What can we prove from the non-fact that Jesus did not choose women among the Twelve Apostles?”

And he continues: “The answer is: nothing.”

Wijngaards then discusses the various discrepancies between decisions that the later church made, but about which Jesus Christ did not make a statement.

Wijngaards gives seven examples.

1. Jesus Christ interpreted the Jewish law flexibly, but he never abolished the Mosaic law (cf. Matthew 5:17-20). The first council, that of Jerusalem in AD 51, declared that Christians no longer had to keep virtually the entire Mosaic law.

2. There were several groups of followers around Jesus Christ: the 12 apostles, the 72 disciples (Luke 10:1-24), a group of female followers (Luke 8:1-4). For example, compare the differences between the Twelve Apostles themselves: only three of the twelve accompanied Jesus Christ on Mount Tabor (Mark 9:2-13; Matthew 17:1-13; Luke 9:28-36).

Let’s explore this event a bit further, shall we? Personally, if I associate further on this event it strikes me that just three Apostles are present and followed Jesus Christ to a higher level of consciousness – Tabor in our space-time –. A mountain symbolizes a higher level of consciousness. They then fall asleep when Jesus Christ meets – in the spirit – with the great prophets Moses and Elijah. So, there were distinct levels of consciousness among the Twelve.

Wijngaards writes about the related discrepancy: “The church would later gradually give a more concrete form to the sacrament of ordination. This first led to the appointment of deacons, then the appointment of supervisors (bishops) and elders (Priests). It was not until some time before the Council of Trent that these three ‘higher orders’ were clearly distinguished from the many lower offices of service that had also arisen over time.” The Council of Trent took place in the period 1545-1563. The church presented itself here as the great civilizer and legislator, formulated the views and dogmas that would henceforth form the content of the Catholic faith and responded to various points of faith disputed by Protestants. The Council of Trent can be interpreted as the (Catholic) Counter-Reformation.[11]

3. Jesus Christ gave his followers the power to bind and loose. And He gave the power to forgive sins. (Matthew 18:18 and John 20:23). Later, the sacrament of confession gradually emerged.
As did the jurisdiction in this regard, laid down in Roman Catholic church law, namely who had the power to forgive sins.

4. For example, Jesus Christ did not determine anything about several sacraments that we have today. This concerns the sacrament of marriage, confirmation and the anointing of the sick. They took shape in later times, although their beginnings may be seen in the miracle at the wedding of Cana as well as the many sick whom Jesus Christ healed.

5. The Hebrew scriptures were the inspired word for Jesus Christ. He did not give instructions about writing the four Gospels or about the letters. Does the silence of Jesus Christ mean that the writings are not inspired? Does this silence mean that the later church did not have the authority and power to determine which of the books were genuine and which were not? These are questions that Wijngaards ponders.

6. Jesus Christ did not found religious orders and congregations. For example, he did not prescribe the structures of the Roman Catholic Church. Did Jesus Christ leave this to the church? Does His silence mean that He would disapprove of this kind of thing?

7. Jesus Christ was silent about more things. Wijngaards mentions, among other things, church law, beatification and canonization, consecration of churches, seminaries, and so on. Does the silence of Jesus Christ mean that there is a hard and fast rule against it?

Wijngaards concludes about these discrepancies and the silence: “It is simply ridiculous to infer from something that Jesus did not do that he set a permanent standard that was always to be observed by the future church.”

In addition, Wijngaards concluded based on his research that “the reasons for excluding women from ordination cannot be substantiated from scripture or tradition.” He continues: “The Holy Scriptures leave the question completely open. In so-called Catholic ’tradition’, women were excluded from church offices because of social situation and cultural prejudice.”[12]

In his book The Ordination of Women in the Catholic Church Wijngaards explains the entire line of research he followed in search of Scriptural objections to the ordination of women. He found none.

Based on his research, Wijngaards concluded that a total of nine arguments are derived from the Bible to exclude women from ordination. He continues: “None of them stood the test of scrutiny.
In all cases, it was culture-based discrimination and not scriptural inspiration that supported the so-called tradition of not ordaining women.”[13]

In a footnote in Chapter 1 Wijngaards notes: “It is interesting to note that, without my knowledge, the Pontifical Biblical Commission in 1975 studied the same issue and came to the same conclusion as I did, namely that the exclusion of women of the priesthood could not defensibly be deduced from Scripture.”

That did not prevent other elements within the Roman Church from opposing it. Inter Insigniores was published in 1977 and Ordinatio Sacerdotalis in 1995.

Ordinatio Sacerdotalis is an apostolic letter from Pope John Paul II of May 1994 in which he confirms that the priesthood is reserved exclusively for men. The Pope concluded the document as follows: “In order to remove all doubt on a matter of great importance concerning the divine constitution of the Church, I declare by virtue of my task to confirm my brothers (cf. Lk 22, 32), that the Church is in no way authorized to confer priestly ordination on women and that all the faithful of the Church must adhere to this position as final.”

Wijngaards[14]: “In recent years, the Holy Father, Pope John Paul II, and the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith have placed their rejection of priestly ordination for women in the sphere of faith. They have stated that:

• The ban on the ordination of women must be definitively upheld as a doctrine that belongs to the treasure of the faith;

• That although the Holy Father’s teaching statements in this case are not infallible statements of faith, he bases his position on what he sees as the infallible universal magisterium – i.e. the collective magisterium exercised by the international college of bishops;

• That anyone who disagrees with the Holy Father is no longer in full communion with the Church.”

This vision is included in the oath of allegiance. Bishops, theologians and pastors cannot avoid agreeing to this. And one had better not have a dissenting opinion, because the rule is stated “That anyone who disagrees with the Holy Father is no longer in full communion with the Church.”

As a bishop from the outside looking in, and being part of another church body within Christianity, I can only observe that, nevertheless, the human mind cannot be gagged. Freedom of expression cannot be erased. It is a sign that in 2024 women’s ordination will still meet a lot of resistance in the Roman Church and remain a hot topic. While many in the Roman Church want to make progress (think about ordaining women or start ordaining women), the hierarchy in particular (celibate, old(er), male clergy) appeals to a so-called justified conservatism: adhering to tradition.

Let’s look at this a bit further, shall we? I find it interesting to explore the meaning of conservatism. Conservatism means: to preserve, to keep well. For example, conservatism means a political, ethical and cultural attitude that is based on tradition. The concept of conservatism is derived from the Latin conservare, which means to protect, to keep in an intact condition.[15]

And yes, let’s be honest, if patriarchy were truly conservative, it would of course never have left matriarchal society behind. I find this the glaring obvious. But is has happened and therefore every contemporary conservatism has a subjective starting point that resonates with the inner and collective psychodynamics and with the level of development of consciousness.

In the world of the Roman Empire, where Christianity became the state religion, that starting point meant women’s oppression, exploitation and hatred. This misogynist culture is also explored by Wijngaards in The Ordination of Women in the Catholic Church and will be highlighted in another article.

What we have seen is this:

Clinging to the tradition of what Jesus said or did is the conservatism invoked in the Roman Church.
AND:
Not adhering to what Jesus said or did was done in many cases by the later church – deviating from what Jesus said or did is therefore part of the tradition.

As illustrated by the deviations from: the abolition of the Mosaic law; further completing the sacrament of ordination; the design of the sacrament of confession, the origins of the sacrament of marriage, confirmation and the anointing of the sick; the unauthorized Gospels and letters of the New Testament, all kinds of religious orders and congregations, church law, beatifications and canonizations, seminaries and so on.

I agree with Wijngaards that women are not mentioned among the twelve Apostles and that therefore women cannot be ordained as priests is a non-fact that cannot be preserved because it is something that is not.

The Roman church logically has the possibility to decide to ordain women just as she decided on so many things that Jesus Christ left unsaid. She has declined to do so up until now.

She also has another possibility to decide to ordain women based on the conclusion of her own Pontifical Biblical Commission that in 1975 concluded that the exclusion of women from the priesthood could not defensively be deduced from Scripture. She has declined to do so up until now.

The Vatican has no need for this kind of imitatio, because it isn’t a true imitatio Christi.

And so, where does the discourse stand?

The subject will remain a hot topic within the Roman Church for a long time, which is only based on an opinion.
An opinion is not an argument.
It is not finding the truth.
There is no Scriptural evidence against female ordination.
The Roman Catholic tradition deviated from the directions of Jesus Christ in multiple ways.
Claiming that not ordaining women is following Jesus Christ in an invalid argument.
That is not the imitatio the Vatican needs.
And with that I say – in the Italian vernacular: basta!

Sunday before Advent 2024, a day dedicated to the Holy Spirit with the intention: The dispelling of Ignorance.


[1]) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inter_Insigniores    

[2]) (McCrimmon, Great Wakering).

[3]) https://www.johnwijngaards.com/publications/womenpriests/wompr2.shtml   

[4]) Ibid.

[5]) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Wijngaards 

[6]) In: The Times; The Daily Telegraph, both on September 18, 1998; The Tablet, September 19, 1998; The Guardian, September 24, 1998. Translated from: https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Wijngaards

[7]) Darton, Longman and Todd 2001; Continuum 2001; Media House Delhi 2002; translations in Dutch, French, Italian and Japanese.

[8]) Canterbury Press 2002; Crossroad 2006 as Women Deacons in the Early Church.

[9]) https://womenpriests.org/    

[10]) The Ordination of Women in the Catholic Church. Chapter 12.

[11]) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_of_Trent

[12]) See 9. Chapter 3.

[13]) See 9. Chapter 1.

[14]) See 9. Chapter 3.

[15]) Translated from Wikipedia https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conservatisme